On 8 February 2017 at 15:34, Mark Foster <blakjak@blakjak.net> wrote:
������
And in response to Jo Booth:
Certainly had at least one case recently with a customer who hosts with Mesh|net using SMTP via snap to an xtra address, that went via orcon and failed.��
They had the Snap MXs in SPF etc��(+include:snap.net.nz -all��)��but not orcon or xtra.�� It looked like Xtra was looking at the Orcon EHLO��and failing.

I'm lost on this one; the customer hosts with Mesh|net, sent email via snap's SMTP to an xtra address - why did Orcon get the email?�� Snap should've done an MX lookup and connected to Xtra, which Xtra would pass if Snap were declared in the SPF record for the envelope-sender domain.

Mark.
��
��
That was the bit I didn't get.�� Snap -> Orcon -> Xtra - but I'm not up to play which ISP is in bed with which other.

I'm thinking the recipient host their domain��MX with Orcon and then forward to an��Xtra mailbox? Either way, everyone needs SRS if SPF is in play at the ends.

--
Jo Booth - Mesh|net
Connecting Communities��