On 2/09/11 9:36 AM, Jay Daley wrote:

or the site supplying it does have the rights to is, in which case the downloader is not infringing because the RH has supplied it to them.

No, I think not. Just because a fruit is in a position to be plucked, doesn't mean you have the right to pluck it, especially if you have to trespass to do so. Example: Libraries are full of books. Therefore, the books are available to be read. They are not available to be copied, however, even though the technology is right there in the library to do so. The RH can give themselves permission to upload their content to the net, but that does not imply that the AH has the right to download that content. Of course, IANAL, YMMV, yadda yadda yadda. ~mark